--- title: "Compare Models" output: rmarkdown::html_vignette vignette: > %\VignetteIndexEntry{Compare Models} %\VignetteEngine{knitr::rmarkdown} %\VignetteEncoding{UTF-8} --- We load the `R` package `navigation` ```{r, message=F, warning=FALSE} library(navigation) ``` We load the data `lemniscate_traj_ned` ```{r} data("lemniscate_traj_ned") # trajectory in proper format as shown bellow head(lemniscate_traj_ned) ``` We make the `trajectory` object ```{r} traj <- make_trajectory(data = lemniscate_traj_ned, system = "ned") class(traj) ``` We then define a `timing` object ```{r} timing <- make_timing( nav.start = 0, # time at which to begin filtering nav.end = 15, freq.imu = 100, # frequency of the IMU, can be slower wrt trajectory frequency freq.gps = 1, # gnss frequency freq.baro = 1, # barometer frequency (to disable, put it very low, e.g. 1e-5) gps.out.start = 8, # to simulate a GNSS outage, set a time before nav.end gps.out.end = 13 ) ``` We define the sensor model for generating sensor errors. ```{r} snsr.mdl <- list() acc.mdl <- WN(sigma2 = 5.989778e-05) + AR1(phi = 9.982454e-01, sigma2 = 1.848297e-10) + AR1(phi = 9.999121e-01, sigma2 = 2.435414e-11) + AR1(phi = 9.999998e-01, sigma2 = 1.026718e-12) gyr.mdl <- WN(sigma2 = 1.503793e-06) + AR1(phi = 9.968999e-01, sigma2 = 2.428980e-11) + AR1(phi = 9.999001e-01, sigma2 = 1.238142e-12) snsr.mdl$imu <- make_sensor(name = "imu", frequency = timing$freq.imu, error_model1 = acc.mdl, error_model2 = gyr.mdl) ``` We define the stochastic model for the GPS errors considering a RTK-like GNSS system ```{r} gps.mdl.pos.hor <- WN(sigma2 = 0.025^2) gps.mdl.pos.ver <- WN(sigma2 = 0.05^2) gps.mdl.vel.hor <- WN(sigma2 = 0.01^2) gps.mdl.vel.ver <- WN(sigma2 = 0.02^2) snsr.mdl$gps <- make_sensor( name = "gps", frequency = timing$freq.gps, error_model1 = gps.mdl.pos.hor, error_model2 = gps.mdl.pos.ver, error_model3 = gps.mdl.vel.hor, error_model4 = gps.mdl.vel.ver ) ``` We define the stochastic model for the barometer ```{r} baro.mdl <- WN(sigma2 = 0.5^2) snsr.mdl$baro <- make_sensor(name = "baro", frequency = timing$freq.baro, error_model1 = baro.mdl) ``` We then define the stochastic model for the sensor error, here we configure the EKF to have the same model as for data generation (ideal setup). ```{r} KF.mdl <- list() KF.mdl$imu <- make_sensor(name = "imu", frequency = timing$freq.imu, error_model1 = acc.mdl, error_model2 = gyr.mdl) KF.mdl$gps <- snsr.mdl$gps KF.mdl$baro <- snsr.mdl$baro ``` We then define a wrong model with respect to the data generation process (only composed of the white noise part) ```{r} wrong_acc.mdl <- WN(sigma2 = 5.989778e-05) wrong_gyr.mdl <- WN(sigma2 = 1.503793e-06) wrong_KF.mdl <- list() wrong_KF.mdl$imu <- make_sensor(name = "imu", frequency = timing$freq.imu, error_model1 = wrong_acc.mdl, error_model2 = wrong_gyr.mdl) wrong_KF.mdl$gps <- snsr.mdl$gps wrong_KF.mdl$baro <- snsr.mdl$baro ``` We perform the navigation Monte Carlo simulation considering the correct stochastic model. ```{r, message=FALSE, results='hide', eval=T} num.runs <- 5 # number of Monte-Carlo simulations res <- navigation( traj.ref = traj, timing = timing, snsr.mdl = snsr.mdl, KF.mdl = KF.mdl, num.runs = num.runs, noProgressBar = TRUE, PhiQ_method = "1", parallel.ncores = 1, P_subsampling = timing$freq.imu, compute_PhiQ_each_n = 50 ) # keep one covariance every second ``` We perform the navigation Monte Carlo simulation considering the wrong stochastic model. ```{r, message=FALSE, results='hide', eval=T} wrong_res <- navigation( traj.ref = traj, timing = timing, snsr.mdl = snsr.mdl, KF.mdl = wrong_KF.mdl, # < here the model is the wrong one num.runs = num.runs, noProgressBar = TRUE, PhiQ_method = "1", parallel.ncores = 1, P_subsampling = timing$freq.imu, compute_PhiQ_each_n = 50 ) # keep one covariance every second ``` We compute statistics on navigation performance for the navigation simulation that considered the correct stochastic model and for the navigation simulation that considered the wrong stochastic model. ```{r, eval=T} pe_res <- compute_mean_position_err(res, step = 25) pe_wrong_res <- compute_mean_position_err(wrong_res, step = 25) oe_res <- compute_mean_orientation_err(res, step = 25) oe_wrong_res <- compute_mean_orientation_err(wrong_res, step = 25) ``` ```{r, results='hide', fig.align='center', fig.width=7, fig.height=5, eval=T} nees <- compute_nees(res, step = timing$freq.imu) wrong_nees <- compute_nees(wrong_res, step = timing$freq.imu) coverage <- compute_coverage(res, alpha = 0.7, step = timing$freq.imu) wrong_coverage <- compute_coverage(wrong_res, alpha = 0.7, step = timing$freq.imu) ``` We compare results ```{r, fig.height=5, fig.align='center', fig.width=6, eval=T} plot(pe_res, pe_wrong_res, legend = c("correct model", "wrong model")) plot(oe_res, oe_wrong_res, legend = c("correct model", "wrong model")) plot(nees, wrong_nees, legend = c("correct model", "wrong model")) plot(coverage, wrong_coverage, legend = c("correct model", "wrong model")) ```